One of the most critical and controversial questions in modern geopolitics—one that few dare to touch honestly: Is the U.S.-Israel alliance healthy, balanced, or morally sound? George Washington warned against entangling alliances, and yet, the U.S.-Israel relationship has become not just an alliance—but in many ways, an ideological, financial, and political dependency.
Let’s examine this through a clear lens of how the alliance functions, why it formed and persists, and what can be done to return to a principle-centered foreign policy—one that serves liberty, not lobbyists or ideology.
How the U.S.-Israel Alliance Became Unhealthy
1. Disproportionate Financial Aid
Israel receives $3.8+ billion per year in U.S. foreign aid—more than any other nation, despite being a developed country.
Much of this is military aid, directly tied to the U.S. defense industry via the Foreign Military Financing (FMF) program.
This includes ironclad 10-year memorandums of understanding (MOUs)—binding the U.S. to aid regardless of Israeli actions or context.
No other nation receives this kind of guaranteed, unconditional financial loyalty.
2. Policy Lockstep and Veto Diplomacy
The U.S. consistently uses its UN Security Council veto to shield Israel from international accountability—on issues like settlements, war conduct, or occupation.
Congress often passes pro-Israel resolutions by overwhelming bipartisan majorities, while dissent is politically suicidal.
Presidents, even when mildly critical of Israel, still enforce overwhelming support through policy and aid.
3. Lopsided Political Influence (AIPAC & Lobby Power)
Groups like AIPAC (American Israel Public Affairs Committee) wield enormous influence on U.S. politicians—often writing legislation and punishing dissenters.
Many American lawmakers place loyalty to Israel above American sovereignty, sometimes even declaring it a “moral duty” to do so.
Criticizing Israeli policy is frequently equated with antisemitism, shutting down open debate.
4. Proxy Wars and Blowback
America’s alliance with Israel has made it the enemy of many in the Middle East, including groups and states that once had no hostility toward the U.S.
The Iraq War, Syria destabilization, and tensions with Iran are tied directly or indirectly to Israeli regional strategy.
This has cost American blood, treasure, and global goodwill.
5. Moral Compromise and Double Standards
The U.S. routinely condemns authoritarian regimes or human rights abuses—except when Israel is the accused.
American foreign policy is compromised by ideological exceptionalism: Israel is treated as morally infallible, regardless of evidence.
This violates moral consistency, principled diplomacy, and even biblical justice.
Post-WWII guilt and evangelical Zionism fused into a quasi-theological mandate: support for Israel became a religious or moral necessity.
Many Christians see modern Israel as a fulfillment of prophecy, ignoring that supporting a state does not equal supporting God’s covenant (which is based on righteousness, not borders).
Israel was a strategic ally in the Middle East against Soviet influence during the Cold War.
This practical alignment hardened into a permanent alliance, even after the Cold War ended.
3. Bipartisan Lobby Pressure
AIPAC and affiliated organizations donate heavily to both parties.
Criticism of Israel ends careers, stalls bills, and invites media backlash.
Many political figures take trips, receive funding, or echo talking points crafted by Israeli-aligned interest groups.
What Can Be Done to Restore a Principle-Centered Foreign Policy?
1. Return to Washingtonian Neutrality
“Observe good faith and justice toward all nations; cultivate peace and harmony with all.” — George Washington
Shift from special alliance to fair diplomacy
End memorandums of aid that are not tied to accountability or mutual interest
Remove ideological dogma from foreign policy
2. Audit and Reform Foreign Aid
Make all foreign aid conditional, reviewed annually, and aligned with constitutional priorities
Cease funding nations (including Israel) who act contrary to American values, international law, or peace
3. Reclaim Moral and Biblical Consistency
Supporting Israel must not mean enabling injustice, whether toward Palestinians, journalists, or dissenters
American Christians must separate biblical Israel (the covenant people) from political Israel (the nation-state)
4. End Lobby Control of U.S. Policy
Enforce foreign agent registration requirements
Place limits on foreign lobbying and dual loyalty interference
Empower open debate without smears or cancelation
5. Focus on America First—but Morally
Secure American borders before financing others’
Stop sacrificing American lives for regional strategies that don’t serve liberty
Restore a foreign policy based on:
Justice
Peace
Sovereignty
Mutual respect
Final Reflection: Entangling Alliances Cost Liberty
The U.S.-Israel alliance, in its current form, violates nearly every tenet the Founding Fathers warned against:
It is permanent, ideological, and unconditional
It serves lobbyists and elites, not American citizens
It sacrifices truth, justice, and peace for power and profit
To speak this truth is not antisemitism—it is patriotic responsibility.
America must be a friend to all, but a servant to none. And no nation, no matter how revered or historic, should sit above accountability, justice, or liberty.
Iron County News is a grassroots volunteer newspaper. It subsists on the monetary and working donations of private citizens and journalists who feel that real news needs to come to the forefront of mainstream news practices.
If you’re interested in writing for the Iron County News, or contributing in other ways, please contact us.